Shanmugam’s “No, No” is a test of our political will

Why did the meeting on the 30th August of four Singaporeans, and an exile with Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, the Malaysian Prime Minister, rattled the ruling party in Singapore?

The background to the meeting was simple enough. The event was initiated by me, arranged by Hishamuddin Rais, a veteran Malaysian activist and writer, and approved by Dr Mahathir. We met, and talked for 80 minutes.

My intentions were four folds.

Firstly to present The Peoples’ Charter for Southeast Asia, a declaration of a new organisation called Forces for the Renewal of Southeast Asia (FORSEA). Of those present, only Hisham and I are members of the organisation.

Secondly, to invite Dr Mahathir as the keynote speaker for the inauguration conference of FORSEA.

Thirdly, to explore Dr Mahathir’s vision for the long term relationship between Malaysia and Singapore, and to examine how the current relationship could be further improved.

And lastly, to present a schematic proposal for the improvement of the Johor CIQ passenger crossings.

Since a meeting of this nature was unprecedented, I wanted to share the privilege with my younger compatriots. I invited historian Dr PJ Thum to attend, and extended the invite to other interested individuals. The format I devised provided the opportunity for each of my Singaporean guests to ask any question to Dr Mahathir. Dr Thum, journalist Kirsten Han, comic novelist Sonny Liew and social worker and activist Jolovan Wham attended in their personal capacity.

Hisham and I briefed the four Singaporeans before the meeting with Dr Mahathir about the format. Dr Mahathir had two aides in the room who took notes.I was present throughout the meeting, and also at the press conference that followed.

I addressed Dr Mahathir on behalf of FORSEA, and invited him to attend as the keynote speaker at our impending conference scheduled to take place in 2019. Contrary to what the Singapore Minister wanted the public to believe, none of the four Singaporeans including Dr PJ Thum invited Dr Mahathir to intervene in Singapore politics.

At the press conference that followed, I briefed the press about the FORSEA conference. The press conference was tape recorded by members of the Malaysian and Singaporean media, including Channel News Asia. It was made clear to the media that Dr Thum was not a party to the impending conference. He did not say anything at the press conference which could be interpreted as inviting Dr Mahathir to intervene in Singapore internal affairs. The newspaper headlines on the story informed readers of my invite to Dr Mahathir to speak at a conference about democracy in Southeast Asia.

The real question is why did the PAP Minister of Law who had no evidential basis to doubt Dr Thum’s or Kirsten Han’s patriotism, deemed fit to abuse his public office by launching a disingenuous attack on them, saying “But I think we should never go out and invite someone foreign, a foreign politician, to intervene in our domestic politics. I think that’s an absolute no no.”

Shanmugam’s “no, no” instigated vile attacks on PJ Thum, Kirsten Han and others on cyberspace. It is shameful for a Minister of Law not to withdraw those incendiary remarks when he was so notified by those affected. The PAP has deliberately resorted to manufacturing fake news, smoke and mirrors to create the new bogeymen of traitors in our midst, even to the extent of vilifying Malaysia, because their absolute political dominance was undermined by the sight of Singaporeans seeking dialogue with the Prime Minister of a neighbouring country.

Such audacity of the Singaporeans posed a challenge, and an existential threat to the politics of dominance of the PAP when most Singaporeans by the morning of 31st August had sight of the now iconic photograph of Dr Mahathir holding a Peoples’ Charter for Southeast Asia, with Hisham and Tan Wah Piow by his sides. There was also another photograph of Dr Mahathir with Dr Thum. The fact that Dr Mahathir had spent 80 minutes with the group also took the lightning out of Lee Hsien Loong’s PAP.

The group’s score of 80 minutes with Dr Mahathir versus Lee Hsien Loong’s 30 minutes in May with the newly minted Prime Minister would be remembered in history as a major humiliation to Lee Hsien Loong. This is because the 60-year old ruling party rested its political legitimacy on claims of competence and performance. In this zero-sum game, their loss on this occasion is easily understood.

For younger Singaporeans, the political significance of the photograph featuring Tan Wah Piow with the Malaysian Prime Minister might not be immediately obvious, but is certainly a “no, no” for Lee Hsien Loong and the entire PAP team. It was an embarrassing double whammy for the PAP because the architect behind this historically unprecedented event is Tan Wah Piow, a name the government had tried very hard to keep out of the pages of the mainstream newspapers since 1975.

I was, in 1974, President of the University of Singapore Students’ Union when they imprisoned me on a frame-up charged. A decade later, during the 1987 Operation Spectrum, the Singapore Government manufactured fake news on an industrial scale alleging that a group of intellectuals and social activists were part of an alleged Marxist Conspiracy ‘masterminded’ by Tan Wah Piow to turn Singapore into a Marxist State. The government had suffered a major credibility deficit over Operation Spectrum to this day as the survivors of that political crackdown are still actively campaigning for redress.

On 30th August 2018, 42 years after my exile, I unexpectedly returned as the main news item, with this high profile initiative to invite Dr Mahathir to a regional conference with Democracy as its theme. The propaganda of the PAP had constructed against me was based on lies, piling over previous lies, over the original lies of their founding father Lee Kuan Yew. On the 30th August 2018, this tower of lies against me was shaken to the ground, magically by one photograph, and 80 minutes with Dr Mahathir.

One can therefore imagine Lee Hsien Loong’s and his ministers’ dismay on the 31 August when their own state-controlled media inadvertently presented me in a positive light! “Activists invite Mahathir to conference on democracy” said the Straits Times. And in the Chinese paper “Tan Wah Piow and Hisham invite Mahathir to a conference on democracy”.

Presumably, the regime could have gritted their teeth and refrain from commenting if I did not invite the four Singaporeans to the meeting, and a roadside dinner after the event. The audacity of four young highly accomplished, high profile Singaporeans attending the Tan Wah Piow initiated meeting with Dr Mahathir amounted to an act of monumental defiance against the dominant party. Against the background of an earlier forum in Johor Bahru on the 18th August “Can Singapore do a Malaysia” when Dr Thum and I both spoke to an audience of Singaporeans, the PAP could see their weapon of fear crumbling before their eyes.

This is the crux of Shanmugam’s ‘no,no’. He had to put a stop to the rot that threatens to undermine the dominance of the ruling PAP. Defiance against the PAP is now treason against the State, as The State is PAP.

The new project fear of traitors in our midst is unleashed by turning the public against Dr Thum and Kirsten Han. Using fake news, and dog whistling tactics, aided and abetted by the PAP cyber troopers, the PAP have unleashed the latent bias some unthinking Singaporeans have had against Dr Mahathir and Malaysia.

When Singaporeans exercised their rights, exerted their individual sovereignty, and moved collectively as a group as in this situation, the dominant party has to reclaim ownership of their thoughts, if not their bodies.

The PAP are doing what they did in 1987. But 2018 is not 1987, thanks to social media and digital technology. If lessons are to be learned from history, this is the time to do so. We should not allow the PAP to once again destroy this latest generation of activists, as the regime did in 1963, 1974, and 1987.

This is the test of the political will of all right-minded Singaporeans, and all those in the opposition movement.


Tan Wah Piow



Sponsored Content

15 Responses to “Shanmugam’s “No, No” is a test of our political will”

  • Evil Hypocrite Greedy Thieves:

    PAP has no credibility, not solely because they criticized the event and demonised our own citizens, but rather the series of failures that are happening, which are now all too common in Singapore.

    The plight of heartlander Singaporeans facing in Singapore has nothing to do with Dr M at all but rather the sole evil doings and policy failures of the self entitled, self servicing greedy PAP government.

    Dr M is just pointing out the obvious, which the Pappies wanted the people continue to be hookwinked. If not for Dr M, someone else would have spoken the same eventually.

    GD Star Rating
  • FakeNews:

    At least this old man who out lived the other old man is not the Father of Sin, who led the country into immorality with his lies and the Son, called d**honourable by his own sister and divided his father’s family, continue in his father’s vision of greed and twisted values with his knowledge of the law of Sin

    An entire generation born under their leadership are pigs like them and think like pigs. Democracy is not going to save you but entrench you further.

    If they don’t repent, this tiny arrogant nation with great influences(in Asia) and a big mouth will have to deal the sword in many…. directions.

    GD Star Rating
  • Malaysia boleh Singapore bodoh:

    “Renewal” means “regime change” just like in Malaysia. Added to this is the limited usefulness of “LKY card” (saved PAP in GE2015) for GE2020 after it became clear that LKY lied to Singaporeans when he said in 2011 that the price of HDB flats will never go down. Lawrence Wong told the TRUTH that at the end of the 99-year lease HDB flats are worth ZERO.

    GE2022 will likely be a watershed election with big defeat for PAP even resulting in regime change. GE2020 will be “mother-of-all payback” in Singapore. Regime change is in the cards. I can see the light at the end of the PAP tunnel.

    GD Star Rating
  • clown pap + gang S$m liars:

    Why did the meeting on the 30th August of four Singaporeans, and an exile with Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, the Malaysian Prime Minister, rattled (sic) the ruling party in Singapore?

    clown pap and gang S$m liars are rattled because like paper never able to cover fire, clown pap and S$m gang never able to cover lies.

    what happens if 70% sheep discovers clown pap and gang S$m lies?

    70% sheep revolts, and clown pap and S$m gang shall need to run road. and because pap clown has abused goodwill with Malaysia, China, and so on, nowhere to run road despite their S$m.

    GD Star Rating
  • yes no man:

    Yes or No answer man.

    GD Star Rating
  • old man:

    yes looking for a regime change..enough of their nonsense

    GD Star Rating
  • Bobo:

    If one’s conscience is crytal clear, there’s no need to worry and feel panic at all. Just do what is humane.

    GD Star Rating
  • Sperm:

    If he no longer in parliament, pap becomes so much nicer a party.

    I dun mean he get captured by ufo la.

    His health OK?

    GD Star Rating
  • opposition dude:

    There is enough anger on the ground even without the activists meeting with Mahathir. State media can come up with whatever headlines they want, it’s up to the daft readers to believe everything they read.

    So since it has been said that these guys are traitors then why have they not been arrested, interrogated etc etc? Isn’t the PAP very quick in arresting people like Amos and Roy? Why isn’t there a follow up news story on the activists’ arrests since they have been branded “traitors”?

    All this, my friends, is just sabre rattling to make the dafts think that something big is going on when there isn’t. It’s true that this has rattled PAP and so they retaliate in the only way they know how, sabre rattling and making huge noise. That’s why they are known as empty vessels because empty vessels……well you know the saying lah, hor?

    The next GE will be another watershed. I hope the opposition parties keep talking about the 99 year HDB lease and flat values dropping non stop since campaigning is only a week long and the message has to stick in voters’ heads when they go vote. Come on opposition parties, this is another big chance for you guys especially for those contesting in the east!

    GD Star Rating
  • Compassion for the people:

    “Knowing others is intelligence;
    knowing yourself is true wisdom.
    Mastering others is strength;
    mastering yourself is true power.”
    Lao Tzu, Tao Te Ching

    GD Star Rating
  • HarderTruths:

    Haha this guy is funny.
    I wonder if he passed his PSLE

    GD Star Rating
  • HarderTruths:

    He also looks extremely well fed and content.

    Is it too much for me to ask if I can havee three meals a day?
    I am sure he will say ‘No…No…Cannot’

    GD Star Rating
  • What’s all the fuss about?:

    Mahathir grants interviews with anybody even when he was out of government.
    He meets up with anybody without any rigid protocol or formality or lines of bodyguards.
    He walks freely in KLCC and allow pictures of himself taken with everyone.
    That’s his easy going style over there.
    He still is the same person, open and he likes company.
    He meets up with political or business people or anyone of interest who wants an audience with him.
    Don’t think he will turn down anyone.
    Apparently Mahathir is simple and easygoing and he speaks up on all and every issue as appropriate or applicable or conducive or relevant as as he sees it at that point in time.
    He says it as it is.
    He is a simple person, not complicated.
    Watch his demeanor and expressions and off the cuff comments almost every night on TV.
    And that include his team, a good team that he has assembled, always open to journalists.
    Compare and contrast all that with what is going on over here, the rigidity, the subdued almost afraid to give own views on issues or subjects that the people want and ought to know or hear about.
    Here it is almost all closed and locked up.
    Almost silent and dumb.
    Here they just clam up, afraid to talk in case you say something minutely wrong and afraid will loose their juicy income, most expressions are common pleasantries and guarded probably rehearsed statements.
    They mostly appear nervous and self-conscious on TV and short of comments.
    They can’t express themselves naturally.
    So Mahathir entertaining those of like minds to meet up with him is nothing new or surprising.
    He has been doing this all his life.

    GD Star Rating
  • MarBowling:

    Notice something interesting and like a sore thumb:not a single word from Mai Hum about the so-called traitors meeting up with Dr M! Only fanatic barking and howling from all his running dogs and eunuchs! Think Mai Hum is very very afraid that if he passes any adverse remarks anout Dr M or Malaysia, Dr M will bite him without letting go until Mai Hum and Gang will Kenna “chicken feather duck blood”. Big Nose Teo and 69.9% What do you think?

    GD Star Rating
  • Intimidated peasants:

    Tan Kin Lian may also be meeting with dry, if not mistaken.

    Singaporeans are controlled.
    They alone cannot skin the cat.

    Dr M is a rare talent. He knows.

    Out of desperation, Singaporeans can only rely on external forces to get the job done. We Need Ft. Else sg Tak Boleh!

    Without EXTERNAL FORCES, Tak Harapan!

    To skin the cat, must think Out of the sg box.
    Think External Forces.

    If you play by the rules set by the cat,
    You can never win. Just like wankers party.

    GD Star Rating
Member Services
Self-SupportMembers Login
Sponsored Advertisement

Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement

Most Recent Comments
  • Same as cdc fund: At best this is known as trickery! Now you see it now you don’t It is the same as the CDC...
  • Just fyi: @Anonymously Error.. Shd read….get the officer’s name and designation… Apologies.
  • opposition dude: Obviously it can be seen that PAP has a tidak apa attitude. Your son(s) mati then so be it, not a...
  • LIONS: Think this ministry shud be called Ministry of Stealth rather than Ministry of Health?
  • Bapak: Do you know how silly we are? The default age should be 55. Now they came out with this 70 thing, we fought...
  • Bapak: @Just fyi is correct. Go early bro and tell all your friends. And after that never forget to VTO comes GE. And...
  • Bapak: Don’t worry, bro. The Malaysian skeletons coming out of the closets will Whatsapp, Wechat, LINE, Skype,...
  • Bapak: For the benefit of the young ones, do you know how tough to work under Dr. GKS? This guy knew his stuff, you...
  • Just fyi: @Anonymously Best you go down to any cpf branch office to enquire in person..get the officer’s name n...
  • WeArePartlyToBlame: We sillyzens are to blame.. After all these years we still believe that we have an honest gov in...
  • 不能治家那能治国: 老的不能治家,太明显了。 华人有句古老训言。不能治家,那能治国。老的教孑無方,老的这样 小的也差不到那里了!最可怕的是下一代星民会学不孝的恶行,。所 以吗赴早越除掉李党和那猩猩婆娘和牠的屁虫更本更不是东西...
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic