Rockets from Batam, statistics and MHA

While it is commendable that the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) publishes periodic terrorism threat assessment reports and summarises the number of detentions and releases under the Internal Security Act (ISA), more details and accuracy of information would be appreciated.

BATAM ROCKET?

One incident that the Singapore government seems to be obsessed with is the alleged rocket plot aimed at Marina Bay Sands in August 2016. I have read repeated reports on this alleged incident in the mainstream media even though the district court in Jakarta had ruled in 2017 that such a plot did not exist. The verdict was covered by Channel News Asia with AFP as its source. The opening paragraph of the report reads: “Six Indonesian militants were jailed Wednesday for harbouring two Uighurs who entered the country to fight with extremists linked to the Islamic State (IS) group, but were cleared of plotting to fire a rocket at Singapore.”

While the Straits Times report was waffling with a misleading headline “Batam militants behind foiled Marina Bay plot jailed for terrorism conspiracy”, it too was clear that the alleged rocket plot was not proven. Indeed, when the six people were arrested, no rocket was found.

Despite the verdict of the Jakarta court, why does the government continue to mislead the public that there was a rocket plot against Singapore in 2016? In the latest 2019 terrorism assessment report, it again reminded Singaporeans of this alleged incident in paragraph 14:

“Even though there is no credible intelligence, for now, of an attack being planned against Singapore, we cannot rule out the possibility. After all, Singapore was targeted in 2016 by two ISIS-linked plots.”

Singaporeans are fully aware and prepared that terrorists can strike us any time. It has happened to other countries, including our neighbours and there is no reason why it cannot happen to us. A single truck driven at full speed into crowded Orchard Road will result in deaths and bloodshed. There is no necessity to resurrect an alleged incident which has already been proven to be unsubstantiated in a court of law to add to the reality of the world today.

Paragraph 14 is not only baseless, it disrespects the verdict of the Jakarta court. It is telling Indonesia that we will disregard the verdict and will continue to use the alleged incident to instill fear of a terrorist attack in the minds of Singaporeans.

This is exceedingly troubling. While it benefits the government to use the threat of terrorism as a reason to retain the ISA and enforce laws that remove more fundamental rights of Singaporeans as well as to enact new and oppressive laws, it does not help to foster good relationship with our neighbours.

Singapore prides itself as having an independent judiciary. Anyone who remotely criticises the judiciary is hauled before the courts under the dreadful Administration of Justice (Protection) Act. Shouldn’t we respect the judiciary of Indonesia by accepting its verdict even if this alleged incident of a rocket plot can no longer be used to instill fear in Singaporeans?

STATISTICS

While I appreciate the data given in Annex A (see screenshot) of the 2019 Report, I regret that it is incomplete and selective.

The table shows that between 2015 and 2018 there were 8 persons who were issued with restriction orders and 14 served with detention orders.

Under the ISA regime, an arrested person is detained for 48 hours and another 28 days for investigation. Just before the expiry of 30 days, he can be released without conditions or issued with a restriction order or served with a detention order.

Annex A does not tell us how many people were arrested, detained and interrogated for 30 days without charge and then released or deported without restriction orders.

In 2015, at least 27 Bangladeshis were arrested and deported, presumably without restriction orders while another six were subsequently charged under the Terrorism (Suppression of Financing) Act for providing or collecting S$1,360.

These cases are important and should be included in Annex A.

Repatriation of foreign workers without a right to be heard or represented by lawyers is a breach of natural justice and international labour norms. These workers pay huge sums of money in order to work in Singapore. To be repatriated after spending 30 days in cold rooms without the knowledge of their families and then finding themselves expelled to their homeland penniless is not how a developed country like Singapore which is also a member of the International Labour Organisation should behave. Surely, the injustice done to these workers deserves an explanation in the ministry’s report.

Interestingly, paragraph 22 of the report mentioned the repatriation of 14 Indonesian domestic workers and three Malaysian work permit holders. Were these workers also subjected to the same treatment as the Bangladeshis?
I hope the ministry will clarify and report fully in its submission to the next Universal Periodic Review.

The latest report “Singapore Terrorism Threat Assessment Report 2019” can be read here.

 

Teo Soh Lung

 

 

 

Sponsored Content

15 Responses to “Rockets from Batam, statistics and MHA”

  • patriot of TUMASIK:

    A SEIGE mentality carried forward from a Bastard now dead…

    Sheeple CONditioned to think likewise the siege mentality…

    Fear Factor with Trained Dogs Barking and Snapping even ATTACKING on Command at the feet of Sheeple to keep them in their pen

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • NotMyProblem:

    Ha, Ha, Ha. Rocket from Batam. Anyone with some gray matters up there can tell you it is fake news!! No one takes it seriously even the first time it was mentioned.

    PAP should use N. Korea as a threat. N. Korea’s nuke can reach Singapore! That was the reason why Singapore hosted Kim-Trump’s submit so that the rocket would not be fired in our direction!!! Ha, ha.

    We have so many Generals in Parliament, not one of these Generals challenged such craps!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Wolf:

    This is the Story of the Big Bad Wolf! Who better to do this than the MSM.

    The MSM is the Wolf’s mouth, Yes?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • rukidding:

    You have to know that Pimps and prostitutes “thrive” on “Fear and threats”….and if it dosen’t work…they will resort to using “muscles”, and of course in this modern days….they also have their own set of “Leegally crooked” Lawyers and maybe even some “aurthoneys ?

    Slowly but surely,….GOD has “quietly from behind”,…make such “faked stories created” by these Pimps and prostitutes ( P.a.p. ) becoming more and more a “lie” !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Lye Khuen Way:

    Statistics from the coverment?
    Always take them with more than a pinch of salt.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • justtryingtobefair:

    Newsflash Ms. Teo, most Singaporeans aren’t concerned about non-bread and butter issues that do not concern themselves or their families directly. We may be a first world country, but our empathy levels are still decidedly third world.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Shenton Way Target:

    Hopefully they will target Shenton Way building where all the FTs work. This will send them scrambling back to their country.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • rukidding:

    Sillyporeans will believe anything those Pimps and prostitute say…what to do ?….thats why EVEN these Pimps and prostitutes ( P.a.p.),.”labelled and called” their SUPPORTERs “Daft” .

    What a joke indeed !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • CPF is kosong already:

    GE2019 is soon.

    no need to waste time on existing pap lies BS fake news.

    focus on PSP opposition coalition to topple clown pap.

    once clown pap and S$m gang start to run road, things right themselves naturally and quickly.

    so let us start with the end in mind. let us focus on GE2019 to topple clown pap.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • LIONS:

    ya,ya,ya,ROCKETS FROM CHANGI BUSINESS PARK?

    i think the gahmen have oredy let in millions of potential enemies into SG?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • HarderTruths:

    All the rocket men in gahmen can get $8 treatment at IMH.
    Free Milo too.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • The Real Terror:

    PAP over hyped terror to instill fear to gather support.
    These incompetent greeds should be sacked for failing to keep this place safe.
    What happened to the silly Private Force, only to serve dishonorables and fix opponents or kids?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Tan Kuan Yew:

    Tensions between countries are political capital that help keep rulers in power.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • 甘妮娜:

    这贴文的作者:

    非常相信印度尼西亚法庭的裁决,

    非常不相信新加坡政府,自己国家的判断!

    对不对?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Bapak:

    They are not wrong. There are many Singaporeans go to Batam to fly their rockets.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
Member Services
Self-SupportMembers Login
Sponsored Advertisement

Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement

Most Recent Comments
  • Blood suckers: Wow so many SMs. Senile? Silly? …. When pinky steps down, SSM? Super Senile? We should go for...
  • Virtue over Self-interest: “… I agree with you that there is a Natural aristocracy among men. The grounds...
  • MarBowling: The MasterMind(MM)behind this ReShuffling Scheme of things is, in Hokkien, Jin Jek Arh! Unless Heng’s...
  • national emotion and pride: //The answer i get was : you should be proud of it and stop asking why…// aiyoh. should...
  • ganeshsk: IN SHORT WE NEED A SERIOUS CHANGE OF GOVERNMENT
  • inclusive / exhaustive clause: //POFMA could also be used as a means to wage an all out assault on any type of...
  • Bad Boy: Current Pedestrian lanes , walkway or pavements or whatever , not suitable to be share with escooters ,...
  • 何福汉: 他是个人才。 新加坡会在他的领导下继续前进。
  • rukidding: The “jewel” is truly a “Good place” to “start exploring” ! Plenty of...
  • oxygen: TWO DPMs BECOME CO-ORDINATING MINISTERS? What happened to “SENIOR” once fashionable? Both are...
  • I like LyCHEE, hate LOONGan: Thatman told the press HSK is the best person to become PM during the next term of G. He...
Announcements
Advertisements
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic
Advertisements