Time for change in SAF

The recent passing of CFC Dave has sparked fierce online debates on the treatment of National Servicemen-Full Time (NSFs). An online account allegedly written by a platoon mate of the deceased read like an explosive exposé, which, if true, depicts a clear overstepping of boundaries by the serviceman’s superiors.

For some, it was confirmation of Singapore Armed Forces (SAF)’s toxic culture of power abuse and its leaders’ mentality of “anything is possible as long as you can get away with it”. For older NSmen, it was a rude awakening that even after 20/30 years of completing their NS where they were forced to participate in illegal, tortuous activities forced on them by their superiors, these activities are still carried out and are fully ingrained in the “culture of the unit and experience of current servicemen”, something which is almost explained in an endearing way.

Regardless of the investigation outcome, there are definitely ways for the SAF to improve its work processes. This is most evident in any online army-related comment section where servicemen (current and ex) often share how protocols are not followed properly, and collectively expressing doubt if the true cause of CFC Dave’s death would be revealed to the public.

The very fact that we are not dismissing this online account shows that our faith in army superiors to do the right thing is non-existent. With so many other personal experiences being shared, the platoon mate’s account of CFC Dave does not look out of place.

This is a military me-too movement in the making.

As such, I would like to highlight some issues which SAF should (hopefully) examine and when necessary, change work protocols for the better.

1. Adequate sleep for every combat soldier

7 hours of mandatory, uninterrupted rest is not the rest you are thinking of – instead of sleep, activities such as cleaning your rifles and area cleaning are apparently considered part of that 7 hours.Our soldiers go through tough training programmes in intense heat conditions. Perhaps it is time to define a specific number of hours set aside from sleeping. After all, with all the wait to rush, rush to wait situations, there is definitely enough time to accommodate at least 6 hours of uninterrupted SLEEP.

2. Rethink guilt-tripping as a leadership tactic

“Chao keng” is by far the most common phrase used to guilt trip already sick soldiers into completing an activity or work task. It works because the embarrassment and humiliation one would like to avoid, which would likely last until the end of the course or even ORD.Peer pressure also contributes to this formidable tactic. A sick soldier might see others who are sicker than him but they do not report sick and fall-out, convincing him that he is not sick enough to do so too.

And the reason for the others to grit their teeth and endure through the training? Not to be humiliated – it is a vicious cycle which has undoubtedly led to many mishaps. This peer pressure is real, and much more intense when one is 18-20+ years of age.

What happened to ‘you know your body best’? Superiors should never decide determine whether or not one can report sick, as it is a right. Cut out all the useless gossip and chao keng complaints and give soldiers the benefit of the doubt – reserve judgement till after the diagnosis by the MO.

3. Treating every sick personnel with respect and care

We are all human; we can fall ill, especially during tough training sessions with not enough sleep. Reporting sick is by no means a form of weakness or sign of giving up – it simply means that the solider believes he is too sick to carry on with the tasks assigned to him.

Superiors should care for men under their charge, which includes the time when the men are sick. Showing care and concern is a leadership trait which our superiors should have.

There are MOs who also act unprofessionally. These “doctors” carry a disgruntled look on their faces and are rude, with some going as far to assume you are a chao keng soldier until being examined. Such MOs should be called out for having such behaviours and have their vocations changed if they do not have a heart for their patients.

If the online account of what happened to CFC Dave is true (read: lack of seriousness towards the incident), this is not only a gross violation of military law, but also evidence of a highly deplorable and immoral attitude they have towards men under their supposed care.

4. Concrete evidence and corroboration; No wayang safety measures

There is a reason why public trust of the SAF is low, with some going as far to say that evidence will be buried, witnesses will be silenced and the investigation would be a cover-up in disguise. Many servicemen have experienced injustice during their time in NS, and they know that culture of pushing responsibilities plays a big part in navigating the politics of the organisation.

Now that a soldier has passed on, we deserve the right to know the truth, so additional preventive measures can be put into place for soldiers to participate in the safest training programmes possible.

Anyone can make a generic statement which reads “temperature takings were normal prior to training activity”. A statement from the Chief of Army would rely on the verbal testimony of those present at that time (likely the commanders) to make that statement, as he was not there for the training on that day.

Would it be better to have more concrete evidence than to just rely on witness’ verbal testimonies? A simple written record of the soldier’s temperature, witnessed and signed by the soldier’s buddies can immediately squash any doubt of false statements. It is a safer and more transparent way to seek the truth should an investigation take place.

These measures will ensure that superiors do not just simply go through the motion of conducting safety checks without paying close attention to any warning signs exhibited by the soldiers. It is only through added measures of written records then can we be sure of effectiveness of the safety measures being put in place.

5. Full immunity results in true testimonies

I am in no position to comment on how the Commission of Inquiry works, as I am unfamiliar with the investigation process, but this is to reiterate what CFC Dave’s aunts already said – CFC Dave was training alongside his buddies, section mates and platoon mates. There were at least 2 pairs of eyes keeping track of his progress and to ensure attention is brought to him when something goes wrong.

Each platoon member should be probed on what happened that fateful day, and no stone should be left unturned for the truth to be told. If the accusations of CFC Dave’s commanders are true, there would be an understandable fear of coming forward and agreeing with the whistle-blower. Just think, who knows what the commanders would do to punish them for telling the truth?

This is why the independent investigators should obtain full witness accounts of the training, with every detail of the incident documented and used for consideration of the investigation findings.

6) One of us died, at least act like you care.
So far, the statements from the SAF were nothing short of cold and scripted, suggesting that his death is nothing more than a ‘problem which can be solved’. Worse still, it was in bad taste for one of the statements to include a statistic which boasted a track record of “no recorded fatalities in the past nine years (as a result of training measures)”. The soldier is more than just a red, underlined statistic in a report, and one death is one too many. Have a thought for the grieving family and spare them the report numbers.

Stop the ‘damage control’ mode and address the root of the problem. Whether the death was caused by the superiors’ lack of ability to lead does not change the fact that there are problems in the SAF which needs serious fixing.

I believe in the concept of NS, and I agree that we have progressed since its inception, which deserves celebration, like how we did last year during SG50. But some problems are too large to ignore, and with an unverified online account of the circumstances which led to CFC Dave’s passing, it completely changed the narrative of how the public perceive the army. We cannot let these problems continue to endanger the lives of our men, and destroy public trust in the army.

Acknowledging the problems is the first step to positive change, and the burden is on us to ensure that they pay attention to these issues. To be apathetic about it would only endanger future generations of soldiers.

We should not let CFC Dave’s death be in vain.





Sponsored Content

7 Responses to “Time for change in SAF”

  • opposition dude:

    Deaths in the SAF seem to be pretty frequent these last few years or is it just me? Does anyone still remember the commando who was dunked in water repeatedly which led to his death? That one amounts to sheer torture disguised as training.

    Those who have been through NS will definitely have a tale or 2 to tell when their commanders were a bit too garang in their approach. We have all been tekan’ed for the sake of it and also under the excuse of insurbodination, falling in slow, taking our own time and so on. This is SAF culture and the old unchanged mentality is that it will somehow make you stronger mentally.

    And I’m extremely sure that we have all either had or come across a siao on spec/officer who just talks and does things his way. He doesn’t care about what you think and makes unreasonable demands when you and your platoon mates are tired. These are the type of people who should not be specs/officers in the first place.

    And that bit about cleaning weapons ha ha ha! I remember when I was newly posted to a unit and all these newly passed out specs were posted in. After a regular training session we were tekan’ed to clean our weapons until something like 2 or 3am in the morning. I sometimes think that these specs definitely have too much time to kill so therefore the weapon has to be sparkling clean like it was just manufactured. So no matter how much you cleaned it would never be clean enough for the specs.

    And for the chao keng bit, sure you can report sick but the MO will also threaten you with the DB thing too. Don’t know why they seek to remind every single guy that comes in to the medical centre. Might as well just charge us all, would be better that way instead of constantly reminding us on the malingering part.

    So just wait for another NSF to mati, with the way the SAF operates it’s not a question of if but when. After all these deaths over the years it still seems like it’s business as usual in the SAF, what with the supposed “safety measures”. The SAF should be keeping its eyes on NSF specs and officers, these are always the ones who cause recruits and privates to die.

    GD Star Rating
  • No change needed:

    Not I say one hoh. The top soldier already said that before the COI.

    They want a real investigation? They should put the dead soldier’s parent or his or her nominee to be a member of the investigation panel.

    GD Star Rating
  • cfgvjik:

    Only people like Amos Yee but able to speak constructively at the same time that sneak into the force can change it.

    GD Star Rating
  • NotMyProblem:

    I am not sure if it had changed. I was in the first batch of NSman, during my time when an exercise was supposed to start at 7am, the company commander would tell the platoon commander to start at 6am and the SGT will fall in the men at 5am.

    Why was it so? Because everyone wanted to cover his own backside!!

    GD Star Rating
  • David Neo Sia Lan Bobo shooter:

    Many ways to keng:

    1) Keng finger cannot press trigger – excused live firing range.
    2) Keng foot pain – excused route march, excused boots.
    3) Declare 302 – excuse army or downgrade to clerical jobs.
    4) Declare insanity – siow people excused army.

    GD Star Rating
  • Hi!:

    HK females dare go protest. (any such must b peaceful). Myanmar swa teng ppl also assert their rights. Msians walk the talk n make use democracy. Timbuktu n remote primitive tribes guard their territories n sovereignty. THERE ARE SIGNS, SCIENCE N PATTERNS WHICH POINT, PROVE S’POREANS ARE IN DANGER, DANGER TO THEMSELVES. WHY BOTHER SERVING NS?. WAR W MSIA?.


    GD Star Rating
  • FuckSAF:

    20+ years ago when i was in NS BMT Tekong, our officer told our platoon to take prone position, we were recruits not exactly sure how, then the fucking PC threw a brick over my head to show his displeasure. Imagine what would happen if the brick had dropped on me or anyone else. Who dared to report on such unprofessional officer? Mind u, it was an officer! pui! o0o

    GD Star Rating
Member Services
Members LoginSelf-ClassifiedsSelf-Support
Sponsored Advertisement

Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement

Most Recent Comments
  • Talk C_ck: William C: Collected 3,300,000,000 and paid out is 133,000,000 Collection is 24.81 times more Who...
  • Crony capitalist costs living: Well, we who belong here and are not educationally dysfunctional are still waiting for...
  • HarderTruths: It is a belief by those in power that one who cannot afford something does not deserve it. Taking this...
  • HarderTruths: Asking thieves to declare what they have stolen would not be appropriate in $G
  • N.Jungne: Rather being courteous compliment, but of course to many of them it is great praise.
  • opposition dude: How to have a pay increase when there are over a million aliens on work passes and permits on the...
  • opposition dude: If you have got nothing to hide then you would be able to defend yourself if someone accuses you of...
  • opposition dude: The anger was pretty high back in 2011 but they only lost ONE bloody GRC, shows just how kiasee...
  • 100%Dun trust this gov: Profiteering from peasants blood sweat & tears. Greed knows no bounds… Especially...
  • FurtherFromTheTruthOn: Pres Moon saying sg the most honest country ?…. Wonder if he was tipsy when he uttered...
  • Brilliant GRC: As long as GRC stays, the incumbent will stay in power for many more years. Remove GRC, the incumbent...
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic