Addressing Singapore’s key public housing problems: Asset Protection, Affordability and Access

Background and introduction: Singapore has a stellar reputation in having achieved the most extensive, high quality and successful national housing program in the world. The proposals in this paper seek to address the key potential long-term crises in HDB-managed housing and to improve upon it. There are two major problems facing HDB housing today.

First, HDB flat owners have no security of tenure beyond 99 years, and the capital values of their flats will sharply diminish towards the end of the 99-year lease. As a result, their life savings will depreciate significantly as they age.

As things currently stand, the value of HDB owners’ flats will become zero at the end of their 99-year lease, unless they are fortunate enough to qualify for Selective En bloc Redevelopment Scheme (SERS) midway. However, for the bottom 50% of income earners, the vast bulk of their net worth or life savings is in the value of their HDB flat. For most of them, when their flats go beyond the 40-50 year old mark, the value of HDB flats tends to decline rapidly, just when the owners need to capitalize on their flats ’values to fund their retirement the most. Neither the proposed Voluntary Early Redevelopment Scheme (VERS), the Shortlease Flexi-Flats nor the Lease Buyback Scheme (LBS) currently adequately addresses this problem.

Secondly, the current cost of HDB flats for first time buyers of BTO flats relative to their incomes is very high, with the result that it typically takes about 25 years for home buyers to pay off their housing loans. This effectively means that for the greater part of their working lives, many Singaporeans are channelling a significant part of their disposable incomes to paying off their HDB flats, leaving insufficient savings for retirement, medical expenses and education upgrading. The problem is exacerbated for the lower, irregular or uncertain incomes that makes home ownership difficult.

The challenge is to craft reform proposals which not only address the concerns identified above, but which are also affordable, fiscally responsible and do not destabilize the existing housing market. To this end, this paper proposes four major reforms to HDB managed housing that will address these problems and greatly improve the wellbeing of all Singapore citizens.

1) Extension of lease: In order to preserve the value of older HDB flats, our FIRST PROPOSAL is that the Government should do a one-time automatic top up of the leases of all HDB flats owned by Singapore citizens back to 99 years once a HDB flat is 50 years old. This immediately addresses the problem of declining residual values of old HDB flats with short remaining leases. The lease top-up cost should be priced affordably at around 3% of the price of a new resale flat, with support for low income families to enable all citizens to afford it, much like current HDB upgrading schemes.

2) Replacement of aged flats: The first proposal above brings with it a technical issue which needs to be solved: All reinforced concrete flats need to be torn down and rebuilt on a 100-150 year horizon for structural safety reasons. Accordingly, our SECOND PROPOSAL is that the Government fund the rebuilding cost of all HDB flats every 100 years. The total bill for such a nation-wide exercise is estimated at $150 – 200 billion dollars over 100 years. While the cost of this program is large over the long term, it is nevertheless eminently affordable and sustainable when amortized over 100 years.​

It is proposed that the Government fund this exercise by setting aside $1.5- 2bn annually (a mere 0.3-0.4% of current GDP) into a sinking fund for this purpose. As with the current SERS, a fresh 99-year lease should be given to all HDB flat owning citizens after rebuilding.​

3) New pricing policy of new flats: The THIRD PROPOSAL is that all new BTO flats be sold at around construction cost of $150-200 per square foot. Such flats will not be eligible for sale in the resale market for the first 15 years to help effectively safeguard the price of current resale flats. One family can only own one such flat at a time. Flat owners older than age 65 should also be allowed the option to downgrade once to a smaller, low cost BTO flat to further boost retirement adequacy.​

4) Social Rental Housing: The FOURTH PROPOSAL is that for citizens who still cannot afford home ownership, sufficient numbers of good quality, subsidized rental flats be maintained with a reasonable security of lease tenure. This is needed to ensure that housing is affordable to all, especially for the less well off in the gig economy with increasingly unstable employment.​

Fiscal Implications: These reforms are eminently affordable and fiscally sustainable, and will leave substantial fiscal resources available for other important major budget items. The proposals will preserve the life savings of the population invested in HDB flats, especially the bottom 50% of income earners, thus reducing the need for what would otherwise be larger state retirement income support.​

Long-term Positive Macroeconomic Impact: At the macro level, these reforms will greatly help overall retirement adequacy, especially for our elderly poor (Section 3). It will boost domestic demand through lower “forced savings” and therefore greater consumption. There is also the fiscal boost of continuous rebuilding of the housing stock which will be renewed to best architectural standards every 100 years. Additionally, these proposals will also ensure all new flat buyers will be able to afford high quality flats that they can fully pay off in 10-15 years. This will release more savings for retirement and entrepreneurial activity which are currently locked up in housing while minimizing the negative impact on the values of resale flats. The proposed reforms are not expected to destabilize either the existing HDB resale market nor the private housing market.​

Social Well Being and Intergenerational Benefits: At the level of social wellbeing, these reforms will not only ensure Singapore citizens the very significant security of being able to both afford and live in the flat they purchase until the end of life but will also enable them to preserve their flat’s value as either an asset to 5 monetize in retirement or a bequest to the next generation. This further helps sustain the social networks needed for happy ageing in-situ as well as for longterm community building. The rental reforms will also address the basic housing needs of the less well-off in the uncertain labour markets of the future.​

Towards a Renewed Social Compact: The value proposition to these four major proposed HDB reforms, amounting to a new social compact, is that any citizen will be able to reasonably afford a flat that will preserve its value and be rebuilt to a high and safe standard across successive generations. All citizens will have access to affordable, high quality housing that suits them, be it ownership or rental. This will be a level of public housing achievement tied to citizens’ rights that will be unparalleled anywhere in the world. It will give Singapore citizenship a substantial new value and meaning.​

In the face of growing retirement inadequacy with a rapidly ageing population, increasing uncertainty of employment as well as inherently expensive housing costs due to our limited land size, it is important for Singaporeans to capitalise on our fiscal, public land ownership and organisational strengths to reform current public housing policy to attain the full potential of public housing for the good of all citizens. The rebuilding, in 100 years, of all flats, neighbourhoods and HDB towns will constantly introduce new urban models that are climate adapted, energy efficient, information rich with built-in intelligence such that the Singapore population can “live, learn, work, play, farm and heal.”​

 

Tay Kheng Soon

 

.

yyy
SPONSORED ADVERTISEMENT
Loading...

9 Responses to “Addressing Singapore’s key public housing problems: Asset Protection, Affordability and Access”

  • my $8 heart bypass:

    PAPIGS are retards and totally devoid of ideas and, having Paper Generals and Cronies in all the major ministries, it’s just inbreeding and group think.
    They ar paid millions and going to Paris for their cooking lessons, all these Perm Secs are basically book smart, elitist and arrogant.
    About time they take a pay cut since the economy is seen to be in the doldrums.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Merdeka Generation:

    Excellent plan.
    Let us hope Lawrence Wong (son of Former DPM Wong Kan Seng) will study and consider this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Merdeka Generation:

    Excellent plan.
    Let us hope Lawrence Wong (son of Former DPM Wong Kan Seng) will study and consider this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • opposition dude:

    The simplest solution to the housing problem is to make PAP the opposition. Only then can a proper solution be found.

    We all know that PAP will NEVER want to solve the housing problem since they don’t know how to. They will just continue selling them overpriced with every launch. And when special areas at the very edge of the CBD have HDB blocks built on them you know it’s a lottery already. Remember Duxton at Pinnacle? Remember those maisonettes at Bishan selling for over $1 million?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Harder Truths:

    Why worry? The forefathers of $G lived on the street. So can your children.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • patriot of TUMASIK:

    Mr Tay, time for you to JOIN Doc Cheng Bok

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • PQ:

    Vote for oppositions than Mr. Tay Kheng Soon proposal will be approved

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • factotum:

    Merdeka Generation:
    Excellent plan.
    Let us hope Lawrence Wong (son of Former DPM Wong Kan Seng) will study and consider this.

    He isn’t his son though there’s a slight facial resemblance and of similar small body build.

    It’s a popular misconception for a long time and people should stop repeating it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • patriot of TUMASIK:

    factotum: He isn’t his son though there’s a slight facial resemblance and of similar small body build.

    It’s a popular misconception for a long time and people should stop repeating it.

    Both are Brainless & SHITTY!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
Member Services
Self-SupportMembers LoginSelf-Support
VirusVirusVirus
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement
Most Recent Comments
  • TRE Techie: I must admit I really sibei admire and respect this son of a Gan for having balls of steel. The governor...
  • Ramarau: Lets be frank, It is very, very hard to find a fine stooge, like him. Unfortunately, these are the people we...
  • He keeps on fighting: I bet mrs mahathir wishes her dear hubby would retire and enjoy his last years in peace &...
  • TruBlu: Hope there will be a smooth take-over. I think there will be one though. DrM is just tired n rightly so. Mr...
  • TruBlu: COMPLACENCY that ,so often,accompanies ARROGANCE is DANGEROUS! What does it matter,Orange or Yellow? Fact...
  • patriot of TUMASIK: ok lah!!!…CI, won’t dispute you on your analysis somewhat similar to my...
  • compliant bureaucracy: CB multiplt time confirmed Eating own words once committed lasts eternally. No way to change...
  • TRE Techie: @Great Asia Actually still got 300mb one for SGD$4 a month. But most now all 10gb to unlimited liao but a...
  • Great Asia: Sorry lor, in China everybody is using e-payment, cash usage is very low lor. Only older people still...
  • TRE Techie: @Sojoürner of Truth You can claim that because Sinkapore can elect who it wants therefore its...
  • TRE Techie: TKL is right for once. “The harm to the economy from Dorscon Orange is clearly quite serious. It...
  • Bapak: For China to fix Hari Gila is very simple. They don’t have to deal with him directly. All China need to...
  • Bobo: Millionaire PAP ministers nd senior civil servants do not use cash. If necessary they can get new (crisp)...
  • people do not migrate: //If sg no f up then pap perform fairly well. If pap f up then how can sg no up.// aiyoh ? sg...
  • oxygen: I FEAR PANIC IN GLOBAL FINANCIAL MARKETS is taking root, so whether it is orange or yellow, it is...
  • REGIME CHANGE is the solution: “Messy” politics in Malaysia is still better than “opaque”...
  • REGIME CHANGE is the solution: PAP is preparing for elections. Cannot hold rallies with Dorscan Orange. Wear a mask...
  • UniQ: TKL, Stop being a parrot by analyzing from main stream medias. You are not smart and do not possess the...
Announcement
Advertisements
Advertisements
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic

UA-67043412-1