Singaporeans Should Not Just Worry About Their Jobs. Courtesy of the PAP, Their Supposedly Safe Savings Are At Risk Too

With European equity markets down over 40% and US markets down over 35% Singaporeans must be wondering what has happened to our reserves. LKY always claimed that Singapore’s success was built on depriving Singaporeans of even the most basic social safety nets enjoyed by citizens of other countries much poorer than Singapore (if measured purely by GDP per capita) through policies of severe austerity, forced saving and state ownership of 90% of the land and up to 50% of the economy. The rationale for these policies, which kept Singaporeans much poorer than they should be, was always that prudent and skilful investment of the resulting staggering surpluses would result in an enormous cushion of reserves. for a “rainy day.” Never mind that the rainy day is always ill-defined and somewhere over the horizon!

One of LKY’s key methods of building up the reserves was for Singaporeans’ forced CPF savings (over and above that which Singaporeans were allowed, or in reality forced, to use to pay rent up front on overpriced 99-year leasehold HDB) to be lent to the Government which would then invest it through its own special investment firm, the Government of Singapore Investment Corporation (originally known as GSIC but now shortened to GIC). What at the time was a very low interest rate was paid to CPF savers (currently between 1 and 4%) while any returns above that would accrue to the Government. At the time this seemed like an easy way to generate high returns since GIC had a stable source of cheap very long term money.

In order to control this huge pool of money and be able to use it as to buy friends abroad and pay sycophants (a euphemism for prostitutes) at home LKY made himself the first Chairman of GIC. His son has kept his dad’s tight control over the nation’s finances by making himself Chairman of GIC in his turn, but has tightened his grasp on citizens’ money by ensuring his wife controls the other main component of our reserves as CEO of Temasek. While PM Lee says he is not paid anything to be Chairman of GIC, the same is certainly not true of his wife, whose remuneration is so enormous that his Government refuses to tell us what she is paid for fear that it would open Singaporeans’ eyes to the true nature of our totalitarian regime and show we are little different from an Angola or Kazakhstan.

LKY’s idea of using leverage to make money must have seemed like a stroke of genius since for most of the last forty years CPF savers were woefully under rewarded. The only problem is that the Government appears to have been very bad at investing the money! As I argued in several articles published in 2012 (see links below) the amount of total assets shown in the Government’s Statement of Assets and Liabilities (SAL) is far too low given any kind of reasonable assumptions about rates of return on the borrowed money. And my calculations assumed that Temasek’s assets were not included in the SAL. If they are included then the returns have been even lower.

This is what I said back in 2012:

Even on the most conservative assumptions there should be nearly double the level of net assets (and double the level of equity belonging to Singaporeans). There would seem to be only two conclusions:

  1. There are substantial hidden assets and the Finance Minister has presented a misleading statement of Singapore’s balance sheet to Parliament and the President. For instance MAS had over $300 billion of foreign exchange assets on its balance sheet which should be in the ALS since MAS is a Schedule 5 company. However the counterpart of MAS’s assets are the liabilities it owes to the government in the form of SGD deposits and in fact its net equity is only about $25 billion. To include both in the ALS would be double-counting. Alternatively Temasek or GIC’s assets might not be in the ALS. Again this would be both a Constitutional breach as well as extremely unlikely as another entity (a stealth fund) would surely show up in regulatory filings somewhere in the world.
  2. Returns have been extremely low, maybe even lower than what the government has been paying out to CPF holders which explains why it has been changing the rules on payouts to disadvantage account holders and lengthen the period it can hold onto their money.

There is a third scenario which is extreme but without answers and transparency how do we actually know anything?  However even without this extreme scenario we should question why the returns achieved are so at variance with the government’s claimed returns.

Before they contemplate raising taxes, the Finance Minister and the PM should come forward and give a proper explanation of the discrepancies in the government’s accounts. They also need to give an accounting of their management of our money and why performance has been so poor.  It is up to you not to let them get away with it.

Of course my calls for an explanation fell on deaf ears. As we have seen with the PM’s refusal to tell Parliament what his wife is paid, the Government will not provide any meaningful information, either about the reserves, why the Net Investment Returns Contribution is never actually spent but shuffled from one pocket to another, or about the puzzling disappearance of billions of dollars put into long term funds (a key example being the Productivity Fund under the PM’s direct control) Lee Hsien Loong’s Government was able to ignore my questions while asset markets continued their inexorable upward trajectory

This all changed after 29 February when US equity indices hit all-time highs despite what was happening in China, Iran and Italy and the coming global storm. Now that we are facing a greater crisis than 2009 and one from which the recovery is likely to take much longer, Singaporeans should no longer be complacent about the state or management of our reserves.

Click to enlarge

In particular the recent large falls in equity and many Government and corporate bond markets expose the dangers of employing leverage using Singaporeans’ CPF savings. If we look at the most recent SAL showing the Government’s balance sheet at 31 March 2019 total assets were some $1,174 billion. Tha balance in the Government Securities Fund at the same date was $609 billion. If listed equity markets have fallen by 35% since the last balance sheet date then this component of the balance sheet will only be worth $280 billion instead of $430 billion. It is not unreasonable to think that unlisted equities (particularly in tech companies like Airbnb or Uber) may have fallen by 60% or more. However let us assume that their valuation has fallen by 50% since the last SAL date. In that case the value of unlisted securities may have fallen to $155 billion.

Assuming that the value of Government Stocks remains unchanged (perhaps a big if given rising yields in many government bond markets and that the cash component remains unchanged and is not pledged elsewhere or trapped in other ministries, statutory boards or government-linked companies, then the total value of assets available to cover the bonds the Government has issued to CPF in exchange for your savings might be as low as $800 billion.

It is possible the situation could be even worse. If, for example, many of the holdings of Government stocks and other securities are through external managers and they have taken on leverage, as Bridgewater (the world’s largest hedge fund and a partner of GIC, revealed recently while disclosing large losses in supposedly safe areas of their portfolio, then the cover remaining may be even less. It might only take another two down days of 20% for the Government’s assets to be less than it owes to Singaporeans!

Singaporeans should rightly be very concerned, not just about their jobs but about their savings which they have foolishly allowed the Government to control for decades now. If there is not enough money to repay CPF holders then the Government can borrow or print money (though they are barred under the Constitution from borrowing from MAS), leading to a depreciating dollar or burdening future generations or they can raise taxes, as Lee Hsien Loong has already said he will. It is not hard to see that GST could be raised to 20% while the top rate of income tax is kept low, supposedly to attract “foreign talent”.

The Government has so far kept silent on the damage to the reserves from recent market falls and whether our CPF is now at risk. This goes against the most basic principles of transparency and accountability but will continue as long as Singaporeans continue to blindly trust them. In the coming election PAP might for the first time since my father won Anson in 1981 get a clean sweep of all the seats in Parliament because of the coronavirus pandemic. I would ask that before Singaporeans think of voting blindly for the PAP and Lee Hsien Loong yet again they write or try to see their MPs and ask them to ask questions in Parliament about what has happened. At rallies keep asking those questions and do not stop until you get answers Otherwise you only have yourself to blame.

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2012/09/07/where-have-our-reserves-gone/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2012/09/23/sherlock-holmes-and-the-case-of-the-missing-reserves/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2012/09/17/an-open-letter-to-toc-in-response-to-their-removal-of-my-article-where-have-the-reserves-gone/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2012/09/17/a-short-note-on-where-have-our-reserves-gone/

 

Kenneth Jeyaretnam

* The author blogs at https://kenjeyaretnam.com/.

 

 

 

yyy
SPONSORED ADVERTISEMENT
Loading...

17 Responses to “Singaporeans Should Not Just Worry About Their Jobs. Courtesy of the PAP, Their Supposedly Safe Savings Are At Risk Too”

  • oxygen:

    PAPpypolitic/PAPpynomics are LOUSY asset builders, even WORST,AS ASSET TRADERS.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Yoda:

    Why is there no daily update of new Covid-19 cases in Singapore?

    The table by CNA that shows total number is not good enough.

    We want to know the daily new cases!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Fence Sitter:

    Wow, alarmist article and propaganda by this opposition politician. Lets face the facts. Singaporeans are clever people. They have used their CPFs to buy their HDB flats. They do not need to touch their cash savings, which they will use for purposes such as buying stocks, financing their childrens higher education, or buying a new car. These cash savings are spread out over different banks since our cash savings are guaranteed by the government’s Deposit Insurance scheme up $75k in each bank. There is no way our cash savings is at risk.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • 2 serious points:

    1)
    Where is our CPF accounted?
    If you look at the funds set aside for specific purposes, our CPF money ($400,000,000,000 four hundred billion dollars) is not mentioned.

    Does the gov even have a separate account for our CPF money? I suspect the reality is “commingled”, as explained by the “highly trusted” Tharman. It was also explained as commingled by earlier ministers such as YeoNH and LKY. Our CPF is everywhere and nowhere in the gov funds, all mixed up and unaccounted (no separate accounts).

    All we have up to now is a sudden proclaimation by LHL that our CPF money is in GIC. If so, why is it not accounted as a $400 billion fund for specific purpose?

    2)
    Singapore reserve should include more than cash and stock investment. Land contributes a huge rental and sales income annually, probably $20 to $30 billion.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • You are right:

    @KJ, you are so right that we have only ourselves to blame. I really think you stand a better chance in SMC.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Great Asia:

    You have seen how the stock market swinging ups and downs?

    Singapore’s economy has fast becoming like that of the US, it’s become an economy for the top 10% only.

    Ha ha ha!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • patriot of TUMASIK:

    To CONFIRM Ken’s “TIGHT REIN in GIC surpluses”…The Wooden IDIOT name Go warm the seat was PM… BUT never held the keys to the VAULTS of GIC…

    It was only handed over when the rising son took over from the SEAT WARMER…

    So HOW??? idiotic sheeple…please remain on all FOUR while the Pigs will be chanting “4 Legs GOOD but 2 Legs are BETTER”

    and when its time for the porkers to be Roasted, it will CHANT…”Maranatha after chanting Amitabha” to avoid being Roasted!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Belief is Psychological:

    KJ

    You do understand singaporeans right?
    The PAP has so tightly dictated the narrative for 53years that singaporeans strongly firmly believe in them to the extent of taking words utterred from their mouths, claims , and regard them as Truths not requiring questioning.

    For example, if I ask a Singaporean, how can you prove the GDP ? He says MAS announced it.

    That’s said, I am not saying announced GDP is faked at all. I am saying that scientifically, from an accounting point of view, it’s an independently audited claim.

    But if someone can debunk me I accept gladly and concede I am wrong.

    So KJ, my point is, 99.99% Singapore do not want to know the truth about the reserves. This is the problem with a democracy. It’s a Democratic Decision.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Lie Con U:

    I nearly fell off my chair when I read about the punishments that will be imposed for those not maintaining a save distance.The PM and PAPare the biggest hypocrites. If every one is equal in the eye of the law LHL and his ministers and MPs all be either fined $10 000 or be imprisoned for 6 months.
    As LHL and his ministers would have known the implementation of such laws they MUST BE PUNISHED.LHL has LOST THE MORAL HIGH GROUND.By his selfish actions LHL has put many the residents of Ang Mo Kio in danger.Only GOD knows if there will be Ang Mo Kio claster. LHL has shown that he is OF LOW MORAL CHARACTER and is truly a DISHONOURABLE SOB.a
    ,

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Malay sure boleh:

    Malaysia 2031 cases and 24 deaths.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • No POFMA?:

    ”the same is certainly not true of his wife, whose remuneration is so enormous that his Government refuses to tell us what she is paid for fear that it would open Singaporeans’ eyes to the true nature of our totalitarian regime ”
    No POFMA for this statement will mean that it is true?
    Brother-in-law Yang also wonder why it is a state secret?
    Seems like the whole world wants to know this than to find a vaccine for Wuhan.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • TruBlu:

    TH>>>>>Terrible Hoaxer$$$!!!

    GIC>>>>Gabra INVESTMENT Cuckoos!!!

    THEY ONLY GOOD AT COLLECTING MORE MONEY FROM PEASANT SGS.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Business is business:

    Budget to save jobs is gonna be abused mostly. This is my opinion.

    Businesses exist to profit. It’s not a charity.

    No business means employees let go.

    Any help in money terms given to businesses with be taken without using that to save jobs because now there is no business and even having less workers cannot keep businesses afloat. Bosses have costs to pay like bungalow loans, Ferrari loans. Yacht berth fees. Mistresses sex fees. Cigars.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Realistically:

    @ Fence Sitter:
    March 27, 2020 at 10:33 am (Quote)

    “Wow, alarmist article and propaganda by this opposition politician.”

    What Kenneth Jeyaretnam posted is based on FACTS.

    “Lets face the facts. Singaporeans are clever people.”

    Really? Then how come your your dead master Lee Kuan Yew had called sinkies ‘DAFT”?

    “They have used their CPFs to buy their HDB flats. They do not need to touch their cash savings, which they will use for purposes such as buying stocks, financing their childrens higher education, or buying a new car.”

    And what’s the cost of their HDB flats? The “what’s wrong with collecting more money from sinkies” philosophy of the PAPie regime depletes sinkies of their hard earned money to enable the PAPie regime to profit from selling the HDB flat which value would be ZERO after 99 years.

    So don’t tok cok PAPie s*ake oil propaganda………..to continue wreaking havoc with the incompetent and greedy emperor without clothes to enrich his wife with her mega million salary as the failed CEO of TH.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • pap S$m money faced thieves:

    pap says need malay president and proceeded to select an INDIAN. what a lie.

    pap says if pap higher echelon kenna caught in pap law, INSIDE 200m is not within 200m applies. this is a good law example of abuse of power, one pap law two pap interpretations.

    pap says if pap minister is caught in error, pap minister POFMA requires the accused to prove innocence. this is also another good law example of abuse of power, to enable pap folks to lie without end.

    pap tells then esteemed son of the soil Mr Ong TC it shall take half a century of man-years to find out the true financial position of our national reserves. YET pap clown last night on pap tv was seen talking as if he knows. WHO is lying? pap or pap clown?

    the list of pap lies is very long. it is far better to write them all into the revised history of Singapore, as soon as New Government forms, which shall take place, a matter of timing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Useless:

    With all the money COLLECTED from SINKING FUNDS all OVR the Island’s HDB TC,

    They can built new flats without $$$, ALL over the Island,

    then SELL at ‘HUGE PROFITS’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • find that certain people:

    //Wow, alarmist article and propaganda by this opposition politician. Lets face the facts. Singaporeans are clever people. They have used their CPFs to buy their HDB flats.//

    funny hor ? i find that certain people in the tua-liat ‘oppo’ camp never kena PORMAR leh ? rather, those kacang puteh ‘oppo’ ones kena PORMAR ? maybe garment know that they cannot afford to let one kacang puteh ‘oppo’ to influence more kacang puteh ‘oppo’ wannabes to do the same ? so must whack one kacang puteh ‘chicken’ to scare the kacang puteh ‘monkeys” ?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

Leave a Reply

 characters available


Scroll Down For More Interesting Stuff


Member Services
Self-SupportMembers LoginSelf-Support
VirusVirusVirus
Sponsored Advertisement
Search On TR Emeritus
Sponsored Advertisement
Most Recent Comments
  • TRE Techie: Actually, if one bothers to do some math, ST has quite a good list located at https://www.straitstimes....
  • Sinkies: Actually, there is a large proportion of sinkies who are born bodoh and extremely difficult to reverse their...
  • fpc: rehash of old ideas from KJ. Basically he is saying, Singapore govt has probably not enough asset or cash if the...
  • SG Boleh: What is the reason for compensating employers with $100 a day for every employee that is quarantined or...
  • Cultural misunderstanding?: Maybe hoh, some locals call him “Singapore lau hero.” This Korean chabo...
  • Lie Con U: It should not have happen,but it did we are sorry and let’s move on. This will the reply from Josephine...
  • Ang Mo Tua Kee: “And if you are ang moh, bathe before going out” And you, bathe before I come in.
  • NOT SOME BLAME, ALL THE BLAME: As above….
  • Harder Truths: We live on this small overpopulated smelly and disease infested island because of the pappies –...
  • Tan Kin Lian April 9 dateline: PAP better have the word “Circuit-Breaker” patented. Trump might want to...
  • patriot of TUMASIK: John Lim: Why nobody say about crowding in trains and buses??? Simple lah!!! put an X on...
  • Nk: Signing of assistance and collection of mask are dry run for voters.
  • TRE Techie: “According to the MOH, the affected 13,000 resident workers at S11 Dormitory and 6,800 resident...
  • Nk: Never install require fixture eg(any circuits) is 100per cent contractor’s fault.
  • Nk: One min.tell people to stay united.next min to stay One meter apart.can go bonkers.
  • Hu Chian: @TRE Techie Without a doubt, Lawrence Wong and team is daft. Lawrence should go to hell. They are making...
  • Tan Kin Lian April 9 dateline: TRE Techie: “Meanwhile, National Development Minister Lawrence Wong told the...
  • Alvin Lam: No one knows how much SG reserves has. Until now ,the govt have not release our CPF during this COVID-19...
Announcement
Advertisements
Advertisements
Visitors Statistic
Latest Statistic

UA-67043412-1